From the Archives: Should Christians Listen to Secular Music? + December BUJO

Hello, friends! I hope you all had a wonderful Thanksgiving! Today I’m posting my third most-read post, “Should Christians Listen to Secular Music?” I originally posted it here. Stick to the end to get a peek at my December bullet journal as well!

Maybe you clicked on this article out of curiosity. On the other hand, maybe you’re reading this expecting to disagree with me. Whatever you came here for, thanks for joining me.

I love music. Music makes working easier and relaxing more enjoyable. I love to put on my headphones and turn up a favorite playlist.

Because it is so important and common, music can be a controversial subject. Some people are passionate about their favorite genres, artists, and songs, and they don’t want legalistic rules to worry them. I can relate to them. There is also a group that solely listens to Christian music. I can relate to these people too. 

Btw: I use the word “secular” in this article to describe any music that is not Christian music.

I can relate to both groups because I’ve been in both. When I was young, I only listened to Christian music, thinking that listening to secular music was sinful. Then I actually heard some secular music and found that it wasn’t all bad. I continued exploring music and eventually heard some songs that I loved (but some that also fueled sin in my mind). I knew some of it was unhealthy, but I didn’t want to stop listening to my favorite songs. Finally, I found a balance a couple weeks ago: listening to secular and Christian music after evaluating how different songs were affecting me and sifting through them based on several questions.

I believe music is a gift from God, and I see the power of music when it changes my emotions and actions. I also believe we must follow God in every area of our lives, including our music choices. 

I have no list of do’s and don’ts. I’m not going to tell you what to listen to, what swear words to avoid, or what genres to skip. What you listen to is a personal decision, and I want to help you to evaluate your own music . I want to give you a way to sift through songs and honor God while not getting stuck on a set of rules. 

Step back and re-think the music coming through your earbuds. Think of your favorite playlists and ask yourself the 5 questions below. It doesn’t have to be complicated, and you don’t have to use all 5. I hope they help you pick an amazing playlist!

1. How does this make me feel?

Music has power to make you feel a certain way. Does your music make you mad? Does your music make you depressed? Sometimes when I‘m upset or sad, I choose music that matches my emotions. Think about whether you really want these emotions before you encourage them. Along with that, does your music make you feel too “dirty” to pray? If so, you should seriously rethink your music.

2. How does this make me think?

Is your music fueling dirty thoughts? Some songs fuel lust, hate, or jealousy, but God calls Christians to think of things that are true, good, and beautiful.

3. Is this fueling sin?

This may seem extreme to some of you, but I believe music has power to change the way we feel, think, and act. Ask yourself: does your music make it harder to obey God? 

4. Does it disrespect God?

I’m not saying every song needs perfect theology, but we should avoid songs that directly disrespect God. I’ve seen the most disrespect in music when the song treats God as a boyfriend or misrepresents God’s character (“God is a Woman” etc.). Is your music misrepresenting God?

5. Is this desensitizing me to sin? 

This question especially applies to the sensuality we hear so often in secular music. If sexual lyrics are constantly in our earbuds, it is MUCH harder to think pure thoughts. I also use this question to evaluate language. Is there so much swearing in the song that your head is filled with it and you’re desensitized to it? 

When we put on our headphones, we don’t just let in a good beat. The music we listen to affects the way we feel, think, and act. Music is powerful, and we need to follow God even when we decide what songs to listen to.

If you realize that you need to remove some songs, do some more exploring and look for new songs to replace them. Don’t just get rid of unhealthy songs. Look for upbeat, fun songs that you LOVE to take their place.

Enjoy your music while keeping your eyes open (or ears open) to what you’re listening to.

Let’s Talk!

What do you think about Christians and secular music? Do you agree or disagree with me? I would love to hear from you in the comments below!

Looking for some music suggestions? Check out my summer playlist and playlist of songs to dance to.

December BUJO

I like to always have this monthly overview each month. I didn’t make many pages for December, but I narrowed it down to the essential pages I regularly use. It’s really neat to look back at my goals at the end of the month and see how much I did!

I always like to record blogging and exercise, and I figured it would be helpful to track my Christmas spending too! On break, I usually have a lot of free time. I waste a lot of my free time if I don’t have a list of things I’ve been wanting to do, so I made a basic to-do list on the second page.

I hope you all have a wonderful rest of your weekend! ❤

If you’d like to see more content like this and haven’t subscribed to my email list yet, you can sign up here. If you enjoyed today’s post, please be sure to like, comment, and share! Thank you!

11 thoughts on “From the Archives: Should Christians Listen to Secular Music? + December BUJO”

  1. What do you think about secular artists who sometimes sing Christian songs (such as traditional hymns or traditional Christmas songs about Jesus) and sometimes really bad ones? Some of my favorite Christian songs fall into this category, but when I know the singer hates God and doesn’t believe what they’re singing, I get a strange feeling. Should I stay away from these kinds of artists? I do love some of their versions of hymns, though, so it would be hard to cut some songs out. I’m just confused about whether it’s okay to just listen to the “safe” ones or not. What should I do?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi, Hadassah! Great question! Personally, I evaluate music song by song, not artist by artist. Think of why you want to listen to the music. Is it God glorifying? Are you making the song artist a role model? If your tendency is to really look up to the artists you listen to, maybe it would be better to avoid the song for a bit. Or you can even pray for that person whenever you hear their song! Another thought: sometimes even mainstream Christian artists walk away from their faith and deny God (for example, Hawk Nelson’s lead singer). Is it wrong to listen to his past songs because he denies God now? I think his past songs can still glorify God. God uses even the most unholy people and things to glorify him. When Nebuchadnezzar praised God, it was a good thing, even if he was a messed up guy himself. Those are my thoughts, but if you have a funny feeling while listening to it, maybe you should step back and pray about it (actually, that’s a good step to take no matter how you feel!). Instead of doing something you don’t feel is right, just give it some time, pray, and talk it over with your parents. And nowadays there are a lot of song remakes you can find if you decide you need some time to think it over. Thanks for the question, friend! Hope that helps:)


      1. Thank you for answering my question! It’s been weighing on my conscience a lot lately, so thank you for giving your opinion on it! It was very helpful. ❤

        Liked by 1 person

  2. This is a great blog post, Rachel! And you bullet journaling pages always inspires me to be more diligent in my bullet journal. I haven’t done it much lately!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Great post Rachel! You’re so right … and I love how you came to your conclusion! Especially your point about how your music makes you feel. I’ve thought about that before but it really popped out to me today. You’re an inspiration, Rachel! 🤗 I really enjoy reading your posts!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s